Why Supreme Court order may not help INDIA bloc retain Chandigarh Mayor's post

Posted on:
Key Points

In a major win for the Opposition INDIA bloc, the Supreme Court on Tuesday overruled the results of the Chandigarh mayoral elections in which the Returning Officer invalidated eight votes, resulting in the BJP candidate's win...

The Supreme Court noted in its order that Anil Masih, the Returning Officer who presided over the mayoral polls, made a "deliberate effort to deface eight ballots" cast in favour of Kuldeep Kumar, who is also the petitioner in the case.. However, despite the court order, the INDIA bloc may face a litmus test in the Municipal Council...

The results, however, were controversial as the BJP candidate Manoj Kumar Sonkar defeated AAP-Congress joint candidate Kuldeep Kumar after eight votes cast in favour of the latter were declared invalid...

A three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud and including Justices JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra physically examined the ballot papers and concluded that the eight ballots, which were invalidated by Returning Officer Anil Masih, were valid and were cast in favour of AAP's mayoral candidate Kuldeep Kumar...

Even as the Supreme Court has declared Kuldeep Kumar the winner of Chandigarh mayoral polls, the INDIA bloc may face trouble proving a majority in the council...

You might be interested in

Chandigarh mayor poll officer unlawfully altered election, lied to us: Supreme Court

20, Feb, 24

While declaring the AAP candidate as the winner of the Chandigarh mayoral polls, the Supreme Court came down heavily on returning officer Anil Masih. Here is what the court said.

‘A little entertainment…’: SC quashes Chandigarh Municipal polls result, declares AAP candidate Kulas winner | 10 quotes

20, Feb, 24

Manoj Sonkar of the BJP defeated AAP's Kuldeep Kumar after the returning officer declared as invalid eight votes of the coalition partners, drawing accusations of tampering with ballots.

Chandigarh Mayor Polls case: SC to hear explanation of Returning officer Anil Masih tomorrow

18, Feb, 24

Supreme Court to hear Anil Masih's defense on ballot tampering in Chandigarh Mayor Polls. Masih, caught defacing ballot papers, must appear before the court on February 19. Chief Justice DY Chandrachud condemned Masih's behavior as anti-democratic.

Supreme Court overturns mandate theft in patently illegal Chandigarh mayor poll

20, Feb, 24

The SC ordered criminal proceedings against former BJP office-bearer Anil Masih, for deliberately defacing 8 ballots and lying before the court | Latest News India

‘BJP can be defeated if INDIA is united’: New Chandigarh mayor hails SC verdict

20, Feb, 24

The top court annulled the result of the January 30 Chandigarh mayoral election, finding the returning officer guilty of defacing ballots. | Latest News India

After SC's verdict, what next for Chandigarh poll official Anil Masih?

20, Feb, 24

Chandigarh mayoral polls: Supreme Court orders notice to Anil Masih for defacing ballot papers | Latest News India

Chandigarh mayor resigns ahead of SC hearing, 3 AAP councillors quit to join BJP

19, Feb, 24

Congress and AAP had accused the presiding officer for mayoral elections Anil Masih of defacing ballot papers during mayoral polls. | Latest News India

Chandigarh mayor elections: SC declares AAP candidate Kuldeep Kumar winner in polls

20, Feb, 24

On Monday, the Supreme Court bench ordered the production of the ballot papers and video of the counting of votes in Chandigarh mayoral polls.

Living proof of BJP's dictatorship…: AAP posts ‘proof’ of ballot tampering during Chandigarh Mayor polls

06, Feb, 24

Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) presents CCTV footage claiming that BJP Presiding officer openly destroyed and invalidated votes in the Chandigarh Mayor polls.

BJP leader Manoj Sonkar resigns as Chandigarh mayor, three AAP councilors join the saffron party

19, Feb, 24

The shuffle in the party comes a day before the Supreme Court is scheduled to hear a plea alleging irregularities in the recently held mayoral polls in Chandigarh.