Karnal assembly by-election: EC moves prompt debate over the legal provisions for by-poll

Posted on:
Key Points

So the constitutional mandate will prevail Vikram Chaudhri, senior HC advocatee)..

Khattars move to resign from the Karnal assembly seat was primarily aimed at accommodating the newly sworn chief minister and Kurukshetra MP Nayab Singh Saini by getting him elected as a member of the state assembly..

However, the Representation of People Act,1951, the law enacted by the Parliament for the conduct of elections to the two houses of Parliament and state legislatures, bar a by-election to be held if the remaining term of the member is less than one year. ..

Section 151-A of the Representation of People Act say that the EC can fill a casual vacancy of the state assembly through a by-election within six months from the date of its occurrence provided that the remainder of the term of a member in relation to that vacancy is one year or more..

But since the constitutional mandate as per Article 164 (4) of the Constitution is that one cannot remain a minister for more than six months without being the member of the House, so the constitutional mandate will prevail, Chaudhri said..

You might be interested in

State Government to amend investment policy to facilitate investors: Himachal CM Sukhu

10, Jun, 23

Shimla (Himachal Pradesh) [India], June 9 (ANI): Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu on Friday held discussions with stakeholders for accelerating investment in the state in the second phase of first-ever State Level Investors forum and said that government is in the process to amend investment policy to facilitate the investors. Earlier, the Chief […]

Haryana ex-Chief Minister Manohar Lal Khattar resigns as MLA

13, Mar, 24

Former Haryana Chief Minister Manohar Lal Khattar resigned as the MLA from Karnal assembly constituency. It is speculated that Khattar may be fielded from the Karnal Lok Sabha seat.

J&K 'surrendered' sovereignty in 1949, Article 370 a temporary provision — breakdown of SC judgment

12, Dec, 23

Top court finds fault in process by which Parliament sought to interpret Article 367 to substitute 'Constituent Assembly' with 'State Legislative Assembly' in Article 370(3).

Corruption, crime, caste-based politics flourished under previous govt: Haryana CM

07, Jan, 24

Stating that corruption, crime, and caste-based politics that flourished earlier have been largely eradicated, the chief minister said ever since the BJP came to power in 2014, the state government has been strongly advocating ‘Haryana ek-Haryanvi ek’.

Haryana CM Khattar rides motorcycle to airport to mark ‘car-free’ Tuesday. Watch

26, Sep, 23

Haryana CM Khattar rides motorcycle to airport to mark 'car-free' Tuesday; officials follow.

From ML Khattar’s aide to Haryana CM: The rise of Nayab Saini

13, Mar, 24

Nayab Saini, 54, to become Haryana's 11th chief minister. Rising through BJP ranks, from state president to CM, with close ties to predecessor Khattar. | Latest News India

Rajasthan elections: Polling begins in 199 out of 200 constituencies

25, Nov, 23

Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot (Sardarpura), former chief minister Vasundhara Raje (Jhalrapatan), former deputy chief minister Sachin Pilot (Tonk), state PCC chief Govind Singh Dotasra (Lachhmangarh), RLP convenor Hanuman Beniwal are some of the key faces among the 1,862 candidates in the fray.

Polling begins for 199 assembly seats in Rajasthan

25, Nov, 23

The results of the polls will be declared on December 3. Ashok Gehlot, Vasundhara Raje, and Sachin Pilot are some of the key faces among the candidates.

Day after resignation as CM, Khattar gets LS ticket: ‘Grateful to PM, JP Nadda'

13, Mar, 24

The now-former Haryana chief minister will contest his maiden Lok Sabha election from Karnal parliamentary seat, currently held by BJP colleague Sanjay Bhatia. | Latest News India

Haryana to organise two-day water conclave on April 26-27

11, Apr, 23

The water conclave will provide a platform for policymakers to engage with experts and stakeholders, identify challenges, and formulate policies and strategies to address water-related issues effectively, said the chief secretary. It will be inaugurated by Haryana chief minister Manohar Lal Khattar.