Pakistan judges vs generals—why bombshell letter on ISI meddling could stir big trouble

Posted on:
Key Points

The judges complainedaboutinterference and intimidation from theInter-Services Intelligence,or ISI, especiallyincasesrelated toImran Khan and his Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf (PTI) party.Further, the letter allegedthe abduction of a judges relative, video bugging of anothers drawing room and bedroom, and much more..

Thecontroversy caused bythe letter is not going to die down anytime soonandis bound to add to the existing political discomfort.Whats more concerning, however,is the longer-term impact.Both the establishment and the Supreme Court have thrown the six judges under the bus for their respective reasons...

But his claim doesnt hold water as these judges were appointed in 2021, which means that they were not in a position to write a letter in his support.Instead,Siddiquis reaction may have more to do with the fact that he is sympathetictothe Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PMLN)and mayview the current protest as benefiting PMLNs rival, the PTI...

While this mayaffectthe careers of these six judges,with elevations tothe Supreme Courtunlikely due to disapproval from thesitting government and some senior judges, the matter cannot be easilybrushedunder the carpet.This isespeciallytrueif there is a second round of allegations, as some media sources I spoke with indicated...

Suchleaks and letters indicate theworkingsof a much bigger inter-institutional lobby that has not accepted Imran Khans incarceration, the PTIs forced ouster from powerafterthe 2024 elections, and the current governmentscomposition.Themilitarys long-standingnarrativeoftraditional parties and their leaders being corrupt hasbecome deeply ingrained..

You might be interested in

As Law Minister, Kiren Rijiju took potshots at Indian judiciary

18, May, 23

Kiren Rijiju slammed the Supreme Court Collegium system as opaque and not accountable; claimed that a group of retired judges were part of an anti-India gang and were trying to make the judiciary play the role of the Opposition

Imran's arrest to help PML-N, Pak military establishment to get 'desired results' in upcoming polls: Experts

06, Aug, 23

Imran Khan's conviction and his three-year jail term in a corruption case have cleared a "major hurdle" in holding general elections in Pakistan and will help the ruling PML-N and the powerful military establishment to get the "desired results" in the polls, some analysts and political leaders belie

Modi & 600 lawyers unite to 'protect' judiciary, but who's threatening it? Read between the lines

30, Mar, 24

Modi's reference to the 'committed judiciary' takes us back to the 1970s, when Indira Gandhi’s government twice superseded senior judges while appointing the Chief Justice of India.

Pakistani judges say intelligence agency threatened them over Imran Khan

04, Apr, 24

High court members allege ISI put cameras in their bedrooms and tortured a relative to make them hear an appeal against ex-PM

Pakistan’s political parties welcome announcement of poll schedule

17, Dec, 23

It was only Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) led by jailed former prime minister Imran Khan which “continued to question the biases of bureaucrats to be appointed as poll officers,” according to Dawn newspaper.

Imran Khan urges Pak chief justice to protect fundamental rights of his party

01, Dec, 23

Imran Khan claimed that undisclosed FIR and police reports were kept "in reserve" to re-arrest bailed out people associated with his party. | World News

Modi govt advises House panel against linking judges’ retirement age with quality of orders

08, Feb, 24

Modi govt has said such a move could ‘empower’ SC Collegium. It comes against backdrop of tussle between Centre & Collegium over judges’ appointments.

Parliamentary panel highlights ‘diversity deficit’ in Supreme Court, High Courts

09, Aug, 23

Highlighting poor representation of Schedule Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes, Women, and Minorities in the Supreme Court and high courts, a parliamentary panel has said the higher judiciary suffered from a “diversity deficit”.

Pakistan Supreme Court allows trial of civilians by military courts

13, Dec, 23

Justice Musarrat Hilali, the only woman judge on the six-member Supreme Court bench, dissented from it. Pakistan Supreme Court on Wednesday allowed trial of civil